Who is Authorized to Collect Copyright Royalties?

PERTANYAAN
Please explain about copyright royalties. How are copyright royalties managed? Who is authorized to collect copyright royalties?



Please explain about copyright royalties. How are copyright royalties managed? Who is authorized to collect copyright royalties?
Thank you for your question.
This article is an English translation of Siapa yang Berwenang Menarik Royalti Hak Cipta?, written by Dr. Agustinus Prajaka Wahyu Baskara, S.H., M. Hum., and published on the 22nd of April 2025.
The article below is the second update of the article entitled Who has the Authority to Withdraw Song Royalties, LMKN or LMK? created by Si Pokrol, which was first published on the 19th of January 2006, then first updated by Saufa Ata Taqiyya, S.H. on the 9th of July 2021.
Previously, it is necessary to know about the existence of the Collective Management Organization or “CMO” (in Bahasa Indonesia known as Lembaga Manajemen Kolektif/“LMK”) and the National Collective Management Institution (in Bahasa Indonesia known as Lembaga Manajemen Kolektif Nasional/“LMKN”).
CMO is an institution in the form of a non-profit legal entity that is authorized by the author, the copyright holder, and/or related rights owner to manage their economic rights in the form of collecting and distributing royalties, as stipulated in Article 1 number 22 Copyrights Law.
The existence of a CMO has practical, economic, and legal benefits, as outlined below:[1]
You may find the specific provisions regarding CMO in Article 87 to Article 93 of the Copyrights Law.
Furthermore, National Collective Management Institution, from this point onwards, is referred to as LMKN, a non-APBN government assistance institution formed by the Minister of Law, based on the Copyrights Law, which has the authority to collect, gather, and distribute royalties and manage the economic rights interests of creators and related right owners in the field of songs and/or music, as regulated in Article 1 number 11 Government Regulation 56/2021.
According to this government regulation, essentially, any person may make commercial use of songs and/or music in the form of commercial public services by paying royalties to the creator, copyright holder, and/or related right owner through LMKN.[2]
Forms of commercial public services shall include:[3]
Answering your question, royalty is remuneration for the utilization of economic rights of works or related rights product received by the author or related rights owner.[4] Moreover, the management of copyright royalties for songs and/or music, from this point onwards, is referred to as royalty management is the collection, gathering, and distribution of copyright royalties for songs and/or music, as stipulated in Article 1 number 3 Government Regulation 56/2021. Thus, there are three important aspects in the royalty management ecosystem, namely collection, gathering, and distribution.
Regarding royalty management, Government Regulation 56/2021 confirms in Article 8, that royalty management shall be carried out by LMKN based on data integrated into the song and/or music data center.
About the aspect of collecting royalties, Article 12 section (1) Government Regulation 56/2021 stated that LMKN shall collect royalties from persons who make commercial use of songs and/or music in the form of commercial public services for creators, copyright holders, and related right owners who have become members of an CMO/LMK. Furthermore, in Article 12 section (2) Government Regulation 56/2021, it is clearly explained that in addition to collecting royalties for creators, copyright holders, and related right owners who have become members of a CMO/LMK, LMKN shall collect royalties for creators, copyright holders, and related right owners who have not become members of an CMO/LMK.
Furthermore, with regard to the aspect of gathering royalties, Article 13 section (1) and (2) Government Regulation 56/2021 emphasize that LMKN gathers royalties, coordinates, and determines the amount of royalties that each CMO/LMK is entitled to, in accordance with customary practices based on justice.
Then, the aspect of distributing royalties is regulated in Article 14 section (1) Government Regulation 56/2021, that the royalties gathered by LMKN shall be used for:
In addition, Article 14 section (2) Government Regulation 56/2021 states that royalties gathered by LMKN shall be distributed by LMKN based on reports on the use of song and/or music data in SILM (Song and/or Music Information System, a.k.a. Sistem Informasi Lagu dan/atau Musik, from this point onwards is referred to as “SILM”). Last, in Article 14 section (3) Government Regulation 56/2021, it is stated that royalties shall be distributed to creators, copyright holders, and related rights owners through CMO/LMK.
Subsequently, a similar rule, in Article 4 Minister of Law and Human Rights Regulation 9/2022, the LMKN has the duty to organize royalty management.
More specific regulation can be seen in Article 19 Minister of Law and Human Rights Regulation 9/2022, that any royalties that are withdrawn shall be collected in the LMKN account and may be known by all CMOs/LMKs. Likewise, in Article 20 section (1) and (2) Minister of Law and Human Rights Regulation 9/2022, which explains that the distribution of royalties is carried out through LMK and given to creators, copyright holders, and owners of related rights who have become members of LMK. As for royalties for creators, copyright holders, and owners of related rights who have not become members of an LMK may only be withdrawn and collected by LMKN.[5]
The basis and notification of royalty distribution are answered through Article 21 section (1) to (3) Minister of Law and Human Rights 9/2022, that royalty distribution to creators, copyright holders and neighboring rights (related rights) owner shall be granted in accordance with the calculations of each LMK based on data on the usage of songs and/or music by users, and the royalty distribution by LMK must be notified to the LMKN at least 2 times in a year. The notification of royalty distribution shall include:
Then, Article 21 section (4) Minister of Law and Human Rights 9/2022 provides a solution when there is a dispute, namely in the event of a dispute related to the discrepancy in the distribution of royalties, creators, copyright holders, and owners of related rights can submit to LMKN for settlement through mediation.
Observing practices in other continents, for example in Europe, royalty management is carried out through Collective Management Organizations that are governed by a strict and transparent regulatory framework. Countries such as France, Germany, the UK, and Sweden have different governance models but prioritize transparency, accountability, and socio-cultural functions.[6] In the United States, music royalty management is carried out through agencies such as the Harry Fox Agency, which manages royalties for music publishers and mechanical rights, as well as other agencies that focus on performance and recording rights.[7]
Thus, it becomes clear that the royalty management ecosystem, starting from the collection, gathering, and distribution, is carried out through the coordination of LMKN and CMO/LMK to create a simple and easy mechanism for all parties. We believe that, as a process and dynamics, of course, evaluations related to transparency aspects need to be carried out regularly to foster trust from all stakeholders involved. Best practices from several countries can be a positive reference in optimizing the role and contribution of LMKN and LMK in royalty management in Indonesia.
Enrich your legal research with the latest bilingual legal analysis, as well as the collection of regulatory translations integrated into Hukumonline Pro, click here to learn more.
These are the answers we can provide, we hope you will find them useful.
Legal Basis:
References:
[1] The Importance of Collective Management. International Confederation of Societies of Authors and Composers, CISAC University, p. 3.
[2] Article 3 section (1) Regulation of the Government Number 56 of 2021 on Management of Copyright Royalties for Songs and/or Music (“Government Regulation 56/2021”).
[3] Article 3 section 2 Government Regulation 56/2021.
[4] Please take a look at Article 1 number 21 Law Number 28 of 2014 on Copyrights and Article 1 number 1 Government Regulation 56/2021.
[5] Article 20 section (3) Regulation of the Minister of Law and Human Rights Number 9 of 2022 on the Implementation of Regulation of the Government Number 56 of 2021 on the Management of Song and/or Music Copyright Royalties.
[6] Yoyo Arifardhani. Kerangka Regulasi Tata Kelola Lembaga Manajemen Kolektif: Suatu Perbandingan. Jurnal Hukum Replik, Vol. 7, No. 1, 2019, p. 95.
[7] Yoyo Arifardhani. Kerangka Regulasi Tata Kelola Lembaga Manajemen Kolektif: Suatu Perbandingan. Jurnal Hukum Replik, Vol. 7, No. 1, 2019, p. 99.